The Pranksters app is out now on Google Play. iPhone version coming soon. Get it on Google Play →
Social Experiments

Pit Bull Social Experiment by HammyTV

Watch on YouTube →

Ask people to name an aggressive dog breed and many will say pit bull long before they say Dachshund or Chihuahua. This social experiment, from Ryan Hamilton of the channel HammyTV, asks how much of that reaction comes from the dog in front of them and how much comes from the breed's reputation.

The setup

Ryan takes to the street with a pit bull named Kano and records how passers-by respond when they meet the dog. Our original write-up said the results, and some of the responses, were shocking. The dog-news site iHeartDogs covered the video under a headline about a man testing how people react to a vicious dog breed, and dog owners' pages shared that story widely.

The video owner has turned off embedding on other sites, so it opens on YouTube. Use the button above to watch it there.

Who made it

HammyTV is the channel of Ryan Hamilton, who built his audience with social experiments and pranks on YouTube and Facebook. In a 2018 article about the creators behind viral Facebook videos, The New York Times described him as working full time to manage pages and make videos for the platform. His Fake Car Breakdown Social Experiment, in which he waits by the road to see who will stop, is also on Pranksters.

The claim behind the video

Our old article argued that media coverage had pushed the public to fear pit bulls more than the evidence supports, and it pointed to the American Temperament Test Society. That claim needs a closer look, so here is what the society's own table says.

The ATTS publishes pass rates for each breed that has taken its temperament test. In the statistics dated January 2023:

  • American Pit Bull Terrier: 960 dogs tested, 87.6 percent passed.
  • American Staffordshire Terrier: 770 tested, 85.7 percent passed.
  • Labrador Retriever: 872 tested, 92.4 percent passed.
  • Golden Retriever: 836 tested, 85.9 percent passed.
  • Chihuahua: 48 tested, 68.8 percent passed.

So pit bulls do pass at a high rate, higher than Golden Retrievers and well above Chihuahuas in this table. Our old article went too far, though, when it said pit bulls were behind only Labradors. Several breeds in the same table score higher.

Two cautions apply. A pass rate is the share of tested dogs that passed one temperament test. It is not a bite statistic. And the dogs tested are those their owners chose to enter, so they are not a random sample of every dog of that breed. Advocates often cite these figures, including in written evidence to a UK parliamentary committee on dangerous dogs, but they answer a narrower question than the one people usually ask.

Why the experiment works as video

Social experiments like this one rely on a simple setup, a public street and a camera that records honest first reactions. The audience gets to compare what people expect with what the dog actually does. Whether you agree with the video's message or not, it shows how quickly a label shapes behavior.

For more street tests of this kind, see the Social Experiments collection, which includes videos about appearance, kindness and how strangers treat each other.

Treat any dog with care

Whatever the breed, ask the owner before you pet a dog, let the dog sniff you first and do not approach one that is eating, sleeping, tied up or behind a fence. Never use a real dog as a prop to scare someone. If you want an animal prank, a toy or a sound effect does the job without stressing a living animal.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the HammyTV pit bull social experiment?

Ryan Hamilton of HammyTV takes a pit bull named Kano onto a public street to see how passers-by respond to a breed with a reputation for aggression.

Do pit bulls pass temperament tests?

In the American Temperament Test Society's January 2023 statistics, 87.6 percent of the 960 American Pit Bull Terriers tested passed. Labrador Retrievers passed at 92.4 percent and Golden Retrievers at 85.9 percent.

Does a high temperament test score mean a breed never bites?

No. The ATTS pass rate measures how tested dogs did on one temperament test. It is not a bite statistic, and the dogs tested are not a random sample of the breed.

Who is HammyTV?

HammyTV is the channel of Ryan Hamilton, a creator of social experiments and pranks. The New York Times described him in 2018 as working full time making videos for Facebook.

Why can I not play the video on this page?

The video owner has turned off embedding on other sites, so it opens on YouTube instead.

More Prank Videos

All