The Pranksters app is out now on Google Play. iPhone version coming soon. Get it on Google Play →
Social Experiments

Fake Car Breakdown Social Experiment

Everyone has needed a hand and not been able to find one. Other people are busy, or it simply does not occur to them to offer. This social experiment tests that with a staged car breakdown. Hammy, the creator behind HammyTV, set up a car that looked broken down at the side of the road and waited to see who would stop.

The two videos above were uploaded to YouTube by the channel Viralized under the titles I Broke Down! This INCREDIBLE Guy Stopped To Help Me! and I Broke Down This Incredible Guy Helped Me Follow Up Video. The first is among the most viewed videos on that channel.

Two hours of cars driving past

According to our original write-up, it took two hours before anyone stopped. Car after car drove by. That wait is the main finding of the experiment: help is not always available on a road, even for a driver who is visibly in trouble.

Who finally stopped

The person who stopped was a man in need himself. Hammy was touched by his story and started a crowdfunding page to help him. The second video, the follow-up, shows what happened next. That turn is the reason the pair of videos spread: the experiment set out to measure indifference and ended up showing generosity from the person who could least afford it.

Why people drive past

Psychologists have studied this kind of situation for decades. The bystander effect describes the finding that people are less likely to help when others are present, partly because each person assumes someone else will act. The idea was first demonstrated in the laboratory by John Darley and Bibb Latané in 1968. A busy road is a good example: every driver can tell themselves that the next car will stop, and they are moving too fast to think it over.

A roadside breakdown adds other reasons to keep going. Drivers may not feel safe stopping, may not know how to help with a car, or may assume the stranded driver has already called for help. None of that shows up on camera. What the camera records is the result.

Who made it

Hammy is Ryan Hamilton of HammyTV, who makes social experiments for YouTube and Facebook. In 2018 The New York Times described him as working full time making videos for Facebook. His Pit Bull Social Experiment, which tests how people react to a dog with a reputation, is also on Pranksters.

Why the video resonated

Experiments like this work because the result is not planned. The camera records an ordinary choice and what follows from it, and the audience is left asking what they would have done. Kindness videos also travel further than most pranks, because people share them as good news rather than as a joke. For more in the same spirit, see Omar Gosh, who built a channel around pranks that help people, and the Social Experiments collection.

What the video asks of the viewer

The most uncomfortable part of the experiment is that it puts the audience in the driver's seat. Most people watching assume they would have stopped. The two hours of passing cars suggest that, on an ordinary day, many of us would not. That is why social experiments like this one are shared so widely: they let viewers test their own good intentions from the safety of a screen, and then ask themselves the question again the next time they see someone at the side of the road.

Do not stage this yourself

A fake breakdown on a public road is not a harmless prank. It can tie up a real driver who stops, distract traffic and put people near moving cars. Leave this kind of experiment to the video and choose a prank that cannot cause an accident. If you do stop for a real stranded driver, pull fully off the road, turn on your hazard lights and offer to call for help if you cannot fix the problem yourself.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the car breakdown social experiment?

Hammy of HammyTV staged a broken-down car on the roadside to see who would stop to help. According to our original page, it took two hours before anyone did.

Who stopped to help in the video?

A man who was in need himself. Hammy was moved by his story and set up a crowdfunding page for him, which the follow-up video covers.

Who made the car breakdown video?

It was made by Hammy, Ryan Hamilton of HammyTV, and the two videos on this page were uploaded by the YouTube channel Viralized.

Why do so many people drive past someone who needs help?

One explanation is the bystander effect, first shown in the laboratory by Darley and Latané in 1968: people are less likely to help when others are around, because each assumes someone else will.

Is it okay to fake a car breakdown as a prank?

No. A staged breakdown on a public road can distract drivers and put people near moving traffic. Watch the video instead and pick a prank that cannot cause an accident.

More Prank Videos

All