The Pranksters app is out now on Google Play. iPhone version coming soon. Get it on Google Play →
Classic Hoaxes

The Swiss Eating Cats Hoax

Every few years a startling claim goes around the internet: that hundreds of thousands of people in Switzerland secretly eat cat and dog meat, often as a Christmas dish. The number usually quoted is about 3 percent of the population. The story has the shape of a classic hoax, with a shocking figure, a respectable-sounding source and a cause people care about. The truth is more interesting than either side of the rumor.

How the 2014 story started

The modern version took off in late November 2014. A Swiss animal protection group, SOS Chats Noiraigue, launched a petition asking the Swiss parliament to ban the eating of cats and dogs. Its founder and president, Tomi Tomek, told the French news agency AFP that around 3 percent of Swiss people secretly ate cat or dog, and named the regions of Lucerne, Appenzell, Jura and the canton of Bern. The BBC, the Washington Post and many other outlets carried the story within days.

The figures did not match from one report to the next. NBC News, reporting on the same petition, said the group estimated 1.5 percent of the population, about 120,000 people, and noted that the group's president could not say what the figure was based on. Applied to a population of about eight million, the 3 percent figure in other reports works out to roughly 240,000 people.

What is true

Some of the story is real, which is why it keeps coming back.

  • It is legal to eat your own animal. The Swiss Federal Food Safety and Veterinary Office has said that the law does not forbid the slaughter and eating of dogs in a private setting, provided animal protection rules are followed. Swissinfo quoted the office on this point.
  • Selling the meat is banned. Dog and cat meat cannot be sold, used in food production or served in restaurants, according to the same office and to the BBC's 2014 report.
  • There was an old rural custom. The Hungarian news portal Index, in a 2019 article that debunked the big number, wrote that Swiss authorities have acknowledged eating dog or cat was once a custom in some areas, including at Christmas, but practiced only rarely.

What is not true

The claim that a large share of today's Swiss population quietly eats cats and dogs has no evidence behind it. Index called the 240,000 figure plucked from thin air, said an animal protection group had first put it about in the 1990s, and noted that nobody had ever explained how it was calculated. The Swiss food safety office told NBC News in 2014 that domestic animals are generally not eaten in Switzerland, so it could not be called a common practice. Our original write-up came to the same view: no photographs, documents or witnesses on anything like that scale have ever been produced.

Index also reported that a ban had been proposed once before, after a petition in 1993, and that parliament declined to pass it.

Why stories like this spread

A shocking number, a respectable source and a cause people care about travel fast together. Add a twist that seems to reverse a stereotype, in this case a wealthy European country doing something usually rumored about distant places, and the story becomes irresistible to share. Each retelling drops the caveats, so a rare private custom turns into a national habit.

That is the same recipe behind The Bonsai Kittens Hoax, a fake website from 2000 that claimed to grow kittens in jars and drew complaints to the FBI. The difference is that Bonsai Kitten was an invented joke, while the Swiss story grew out of a real campaign with an exaggerated number attached.

How to check a claim like this

  • Look for the original source of any number, and ask how it was measured.
  • Check whether reports agree with each other. Here, 1.5 and 3 percent were quoted for the same petition.
  • Look for an official response. Swiss authorities answered this one directly.

For more famous fakes and pranks, read our Historical Pranks list and the story of Uri Geller.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do the Swiss really eat cats and dogs?

Very rarely, if at all. Eating your own animal in private is not illegal in Switzerland, and it was once a rare rural custom, but Swiss authorities have said it is not a common practice. The claim that 3 percent of the population does it has no evidence behind it.

Is it legal to eat cats in Switzerland?

Swiss law does not forbid people from slaughtering and eating their own cats or dogs in private, provided animal protection rules are followed. Selling the meat or serving it in restaurants is banned.

Who started the Swiss eating cats story?

The 2014 version came from the Swiss animal protection group SOS Chats Noiraigue, whose president told AFP that around 3 percent of Swiss people secretly eat cat or dog while launching a petition for a ban.

Is cat a traditional Christmas dish in Switzerland?

Reports in 2014 said it appeared on Christmas menus in some areas, and Index wrote in 2019 that it was once an occasional custom. There is no evidence it is common today.

Did Switzerland ban eating cats and dogs?

Not as of the reports we found. Index reported that a 1993 proposal to ban it was rejected by parliament, and the 2014 petition sought a new ban.